Athens. The moment just before the earlier moment. documenta 14. What preceded this moment is extremely interesting, a gesture \u2013 and we shouldn\u2019t lose sight of the fact that gestures can be empty \u2013 that led to documenta being inaugurated first in Athens and then in Kassel. Germany and Greece, two Europes, two pasts, two political situations, a general tension. And a series of questions that will hover over the whole event: What can art do, or what should it do? Do we need illustrations? For whom are illustrations meant? What capacity for real action do large-scale artistic events actually have?<\/p>\n
A process based on discursive thought and produced through debate, a concatenation of contents that presuppose a continuation. Paul Preciado in action, a coming apart of everything starting from parallel elements, an alteration of the order and a transcending of the pre-established. Or perhaps the confidence and the desire that it be this way, for the fall will come later. \u2019Later\u2019 appears as the moment of the display, with the opening of documenta 14 in Athens. And this is where everything comes apart, though not for the best. I can speak of failure, and not in the positive sense. After five years, improvisation: documenta will open later than foreseen, for everything is happening at the last minute. The moment that it was supposed to open at the Odeion building, one of the prominent exhibition spaces, there is basically chaos. And we expect a lot more from documenta than we do from any other exhibition. It\u2019s once every five years, remember. It\u2019s something that is supposed to mark the development of at least five more years. It\u2019s something that has to change the way in which we understand art. And yes, it\u2019s not easy.<\/p>\n
And there\u2019s no change, no reformulation; instead, the shoddiness is covered by a cool layer of presumed new education and presumed new politics. But even worse than the disappointment is the fact of finding something that smells of a classical and basic academic exercise: you have a result you have come across beforehand (in this case the result is \u2019hey, the world is in a really bad state\u2019) and you set up a supposed investigation with several lines in order to get there. The more lines the better, the more pages the better, the more quotes the better, the more boredom the better, the more distance the better. And you fill it with images that illustrate the result and yet are not strong enough to take your discourse apart (the \u2019hey, the world is in a really bad state\u2019 is at once the discourse and the result). Something that is already closed, implying that everything is alright as it has all been decided. The exhibition is dead. You\u2019ve decided to kill the exhibition to make sure it doesn\u2019t touch you. Furthermore, it turns out that it\u2019s not a large exhibition but a series of small exhibitions that you have probably already seen before. And the hint that it\u2019s all a preamble for Kassel.<\/p>\n
The parts. At Odeion, the Conservatoire of Athens, a quite fine exhibition starting from a classical construction of sound and sound practices that lead to performativity. No gender dispute or instability are found here, although there are always works that deserve a mention, like those by Pauline Oliveros (in \u2019historical recovery\u2019 mode); Theo Eshetu, with a film in which different aesthetic, documentary and narrative typologies regarding identity are called into question; or a 2007 video by Ben Russell presenting a blend of fury, dance and sweat combined with danger. At the Fine Arts School, a quite fine exhibition that could be signed by any orderly art fair. Once inside, I think I could just as well be at Frieze; that being in this place (with its livid yet silenced fine arts students) isn\u2019t important; that the aesthetics of the exhibition is just the same as usual \u2014 it\u2019s norm<\/i>. Needless to say, there are good works too, of course, like the film by Rosalind Nashashibi, who verges on being an \u2019external\u2019 artist; the historical brutality treated in the present by Artur Zmijewski, with new concentration camps and poverty ghettoes; or the aestheticisation of politics and migration by Bouchra Khalili. Two venues, the first staging an exhibition that would be right for any medium-sized art centre of average interest, and the second paralleling the limit between a select art-fair aesthetics and an expression of political will in a deteriorated context, outside the exhibition. But again, we expect more from documenta and here this conceptual bonus, this variation, this absolute reconsideration is missing. However many smidgens of Sami art you may add.<\/p>\n
At EMST, the new national contemporary art museum in Athens, the disaster takes shape. The presumed historical grounds of discourse merely deny possibilities by corseting. The works are obviously illustrations and are not allowed to become real action in the present. Yet the discourse is only this basic result, and so the exhibition proposal eliminates all possibility of action for art. And it is classical, and historical, and the exhibition language is normative \u2013 extremely normative \u2013 and as conservative as can be. I don\u2019t understand what has happened between these previous moments of destabilisation and this low-profile academic exercise. Low profile too in the archive option, that things can be done well, and yet this isn\u2019t the case. The desire in those visiting the exhibition continues and Daniel Garc\u00eda And\u00fajar conquers Instagram as his work is more colourful and people realise they need empathy. They put Annie Sprinkle and Beth Stephens under an escalator, so any real and sensual option in their bed becomes an impossibility. The few elements that could prove interesting go unnoticed and what is intended to be emphasised is, once again, a supposedly decolonial scent that is tr\u00e8s bien but untained. Unnecessary too.<\/p>\n
Then come the places in the city in which you will not have the weight of the exhibition and its language (as if you\u2019d been unable to avoid it earlier, of course). So it doesn\u2019t work. For a start, a problem with categorisations: putting short performances and things that aren\u2019t short performances in the same boat. So, if you\u2019ve got a map with over forty external locations in progress it looks as if you\u2019ve been working hard. Or perhaps not so hard, if a fair number of them consist of a nice little performance programme. Memorable are a flat with a crazy installation by Andreas Angelidakis that would work well at DIS\u2019s Berlin biennale and a venue like the Polytechnion, a place as incredibly charged with meaning and power that the works that documenta presents here disappear completely.<\/p>\n
In a taxi, looking for some sheep dyed with indigo (that we don\u2019t find, just as I won\u2019t be able to find anything on Roger Bernat, however much I may try, ask or confront staff\u2019s absolute ignorance) we learn of a terrorist attack carried out at that precise moment in the heart of Stockholm. The four of us travelling inside the taxi live in Stockholm. A deadly silence and a deluge of SMS. And then it\u2019s time to consider the political meaning of this documenta and how little it touches us personally, the insufficient change it has brought to artistic functioning and its lack of emotion \u2014 which is the least we expect. We could also ask how people move from something that could be a genuine reconsideration to a pompous commercial gesture. And yes, it\u2019s not easy. Thinking of gestures and the dislocation of space was also part of Okwui Enwezor\u2019s documenta; looking to new fields was also a trait of Catherine David\u2019s documenta. Even marking other locations on maps could be a gesture as politically empty as the fact that a table in a restaurant on the Costa Brava was a physical part of documenta 12. Like Athens.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"
Athens. The moment just before the earlier moment. documenta 14. What preceded this moment is extremely interesting, a gesture \u2013 and we shouldn\u2019t lose sight of the fact that gestures…<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1238,"featured_media":21188,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_relevanssi_hide_post":"","_relevanssi_hide_content":"","_relevanssi_pin_for_all":"","_relevanssi_pin_keywords":"","_relevanssi_unpin_keywords":"","_relevanssi_related_keywords":"","_relevanssi_related_include_ids":"","_relevanssi_related_exclude_ids":"","_relevanssi_related_no_append":"","_relevanssi_related_not_related":"","_relevanssi_related_posts":"","_relevanssi_noindex_reason":"","footnotes":""},"categories":[5135],"tags":[],"coauthors":[6375],"acf":[],"yoast_head":"\n